Skip to main content

Feature First

Film Reviews

‘Paper Tiger’ CIFF Review: An Ode to Brotherly Love

James Gray’s newest film, Paper Tiger, is an endearing thriller about the lengths we would go to for our family when they’re in an impossible situation.

‘Paper Tiger’ CIFF Review: An Ode to Brotherly Love

For some children, having an older brother is one of the great miseries of life. They steal your food in the fridge with your name on it, purposely lie to you about your parents adopting you, and don’t listen to you when you tell them to stop. However, once something serious goes down involving the adults in your inner circle, they may just be the only person you can lean on who understands what you feel. As a middle child with an older brother three years older than me and a younger half-brother ten years younger, I’ve always had an interesting relationship with my brothers. Growing up, I always wanted to hang out with my older brother. Even if he wanted to just be left alone on his Xbox 360 while I played PS3, there was something special about having a built-in best friend, and I believe a lot of siblings share this sentiment. However, we’d grow apart as the years went on, and we each went through puberty at different stages.

When my little brother was born, I felt the rift between my older brother and me growing as he wanted nothing to do with the “babies” of the family. My little brother became my mini-me, as I had vowed to have a close relationship with him, full of experiences together, since my older brother wanted nothing to do with me as a child. As I watched this infant and helped raise him when needed, I began to understand the power of being an older brother, a sort of guiding light to the younger siblings but not an authoritative presence like a parent. I’d wonder if my older brother and I would ever become as close as my little brother and I. Then, my family experienced two losses of family members within 5 months of each other, and that experience has made my older brother and I the closest we’ve ever been, and still are. So, to see that arc take place onscreen in a film like James Gray’s Paper Tiger meant the absolute world to me, and made me realize that maybe I wasn’t alone in always feeling more connected to my brothers than anybody else.

‘Paper Tiger’ CIFF Review: An Ode to Brotherly Love
Paper Tiger / Image Courtesy of Neon

James Gray’s Paper Tiger follows brothers Gary & Irwin Pearl (Adam Driver & Miles Teller) in 1980s New York City as the pair get entangled in a job that sounds too good to be true with the Russian Mafia, attracting the attention of mob boss Simeon Bogoyavich (Victor Ptak) and throwing Irwin’s family into danger. Meanwhile, Irwin’s wife, Hester (Scarlett Johansson), deals with issues of her own as their two children, Scott & Ben (Gavin Goudey & Roman Engel), try to understand what is happening to their family.

The main ensemble truly feels like a tight-knit unit, with an early dinner scene where Gary shows up being a true highlight, as it feels like sitting down with your loved ones after far too long of time has passed. The chemistry between Teller & Driver is truly astounding, as so many moments between the two reminded me of petty arguments I’ve had with my brothers, whilst having an immense amount of care for one another. Scarlett Johansson also gives one of the year’s best supporting roles as she struggles to make sense of everything her husband & brother-in-law have gotten their family into. Goudey & Engel are great as well as a pair of bickering teenage brothers who just want their life to remain as familiar and normal as possible. Their arc of being cold towards each other at the start of the film to becoming as close as Teller & Driver’s characters are is among my favorite story moments of the year.

‘Paper Tiger’ CIFF Review: An Ode to Brotherly Love
Paper Tiger / Image Courtesy of Neon

The 35mm cinematography from Joaquín Basca-Asay is among the year’s best as it expertly puts audiences in the 1980s while having some of the most textured and beautiful images I’ve seen this year. The cinematography adds so much tension as well to some of the best sequences I’ve seen this year. There are two sequences (the Pearl residence late at night & a Tall Grass set piece) that are truly among some of my favorite scenes of all time. Gray’s ability to manipulate sound and expert use of shadows make these scenes soar off the screen and will be burned into audiences’ minds. 

While I’ve sung my praises for this film, the one negative I will say that held me back from thinking this is a masterpiece is the runtime. There are so many moments throughout the 115 minutes of this film that I wanted to sit in longer and just soak up the atmosphere even more; if this were 15 minutes longer, I’d feel the story would have even more impact than it does. Paper Tiger is an amazing crime drama that truly makes audiences feel close to its characters; its visuals, direction, and performances are among 2026’s best, while its runtime made me wish for just a little bit more time in this world. 

‘Paper Tiger’ CIFF Review: An Ode to Brotherly Love
Paper Tiger / Image Courtesy of Neon

Paper Tiger was written and directed by James Gray. The film stars Adam Driver, Miles Teller, Scarlett Johansson, Gavin Goudey, Roman Engel, Victor Ptak, and Cindy Katz.

Paper Tiger had a screening at the 62nd Chicago International Film Festival on October 23rd. The film was released in select theaters in NYC/LA on November 13, before expanding nationwide Thanksgiving. 

Thanks for reading this Paper Tiger review. For more, stay tuned here at Feature First.

Jack is an aspiring filmmaker based in Chicago who writes about films at Feature First.